There was a man who came up to me at our Recreational Music Center table during last month’s Movie Mania event in Liberty Station. He asked me “why would I want to play an instrument when I get so much enjoyment from listening to it?”. At first I was taken back by this man and his question as he was quite aggressive in his delivery and seemed more eager to cause offense rather than actually receive an answer. Nevertheless I responded to him by saying “because there is something so special about playing music on an instrument that cannot be experienced in any other way. What is even more amazing is creating your own music that is your own personal expression and sharing that with others”.
In the days that followed I continued to ponder this man’s question and found it rather profound in some ways. His question, regardless of its intent, actually brought up several other interesting questions:
1) Why would someone want to learn how to play a musical instrument?
2) In this current day and age where everything is so easily “downloaded” to us what does music making have to offer that will capture and hold the attention of today’s potential musicians?
3) Is there really any value in learning a musical instrument?
Now I will admit up front that there are plenty of people who could answer these simple questions with much more eloquence than I and do it in a much more convincing way, no doubt, than what I am about to offer. That said, the answers that I came up with are based simply on my own music making experiences and for that reason alone I believe they are worth sharing with you.
1) The reason I decided to learn to play an instrument was initially because I was curious. I would listen to music and see musicians playing and it looked like so much fun and thought maybe I could do that. It wasn’t until I started taking music lessons that I began to figure out the real reason I wanted to play an instrument. I discovered that the real value of music making for my life was that I could create the music to the songs that were in my head. Simply put, I wanted to write songs but needed the music in order fully capture my ideas. Once I discovered this desire my whole focus for playing music changed as did the instrument I was learning. I then decided to stop taking drum lessons so that I could begin to learn how to play the guitar.
2) No matter what people say and in spite of the “digital age” in which we find ourselves in today, human nature has always and will always resist anything that requires long term investment and commitment. This is not something new and cannot be blamed on the internet or the speed at which information and knowledge can now be transferred from one part of the world to another. The only thing that changes from generation to generation is the excuses for why one decides not to invest or commit. With this in mind the challenges that face today’s potential musicians are similar to that of prior generations, DISTRACTIONS.
For me the distraction from learning the guitar was sports. I have always loved to play, watch, and listen to all types of sports. So in order for me to make time for music I had to find something in it that would help me to overcome the distraction (in this case a baseball game on the radio or a pick up game of basketball down the street). What I found was something very basic and practical (sorry to disappoint those who were hoping for something divine or miraculous). I discovered that the satisfaction that came from making music was equal to and sometimes greater than what I gained from watching a football game on TV or playing soccer with my friends. Therefore I found value in spending time learning to play my instrument. Interestingly enough, the moment I had found value in what I was doing every time a learned something new or achieved a particular goal my love for the process grew as did the amount of time I invested in it. Something that had initially begun as a good idea had now become a PASSION.
3) What is the value of learning to play a musical instrument? For me it was the uncovering of a desire that I only truly discovered when I began to take music lessons. The value of music in my life continues to change with every passing year. It is not one particular attribute but many accumulative gifts that I have received in my life through music. The most important being the original soundtrack of my life journaled in every song I write and every original composition I create. For this no value can be assigned as it lives within the core of who I am. The amazing thing about music making is that it is available to every single person on Earth, and the same values that I have drawn from it throughout my life is there for you as well.
So the question is not why should I play when I can listen, but rather why would you only settle for listening when you can PLAY?!
Find out more about the Recreational Music Center and our music lessons by clicking here.